What is "trance" and how to opinions about it differ?

What Is "Trance," and How Do Opinions About It Differ?

The word trance is used in many different ways. It can describe the focused experience associated with hypnosis, deep absorption in music or an activity, meditative experiences, religious ceremonies, and certain forms of ritual or spiritual practice.

But what exactly is a trance? Is it an altered state of consciousness, a form of deep relaxation, a psychological process, or simply a way of describing an experience in which someone becomes absorbed in something?

Interestingly, the answer depends partly on whom you ask.

Hypnotherapists, psychologists, neuroscientists, anthropologists, spiritual practitioners, and members of different cultural traditions may use the word trance to describe different experiences. Even among hypnosis researchers, there are differing opinions about whether hypnosis involves a special state of consciousness or can be explained through ordinary psychological processes such as attention, imagination, expectation, and suggestion.¹

Understanding these different perspectives makes the subject much more interesting. It also helps separate scientific explanations from personal interpretations, cultural beliefs, and popular misconceptions.

Let's explore what trance means, how it is experienced, and why opinions about it differ.

What Does the Word "Trance" Mean?

In general terms, a trance is commonly understood as a condition of focused attention, absorption, or altered awareness in which a person's usual experience of their surroundings, thoughts, or sense of self may change.

However, there is no single universally accepted definition that covers every experience described as a trance.

The term is used across several disciplines, including psychology, neuroscience, anthropology, religious studies, and hypnotherapy.

Depending on the context, it may describe:

  • Deep absorption in an activity or experience.

  • A hypnotic experience involving responsiveness to suggestions.

  • A meditative or contemplative experience.

  • An experience associated with religious or spiritual rituals.

  • Rhythmic or movement-based experiences involving dance or music.

  • Experiences involving changes in awareness, identity, or perceived control.

Some people associate trance with relaxation, while others describe intense concentration, emotional involvement, unusual bodily sensations, or a sense of disconnection from their immediate surroundings.

Not everyone experiences trance in the same way, and a person does not necessarily need to experience dramatic changes in awareness to describe themselves as having entered a trance-like condition.

An important distinction is that trance is a broad descriptive term, not a single medical diagnosis or a precisely defined neurological condition. Researchers therefore need to specify which kind of trance they are studying rather than assuming that all experiences described by the word are equivalent.²

What Is the Difference Between Trance and Hypnosis?

Trance and hypnosis are closely related terms, but they are not necessarily interchangeable.

Hypnosis generally refers to a procedure or experience involving focused attention and responsiveness to suggestions. It may involve a formal induction, although hypnotic suggestions can also be used without a lengthy induction.

Trance is a broader term that can describe various experiences involving changes in awareness, attention, or subjective experience.

In hypnotherapy, the expression hypnotic trance is often used to describe the experience associated with hypnosis.

For example, a hypnotherapist might guide someone through a relaxation exercise, encourage focused attention, and introduce suggestions intended to support a particular therapeutic goal. The resulting experience may be described as a hypnotic trance.

However, trance-like experiences can also occur outside formal hypnosis.

Someone who becomes completely absorbed in a musical performance, for example, might describe the experience as being in a trance. A person participating in a religious ceremony might use the same word to describe an entirely different experience.

The important point is that not every trance is hypnosis, and not every hypnotic experience needs to resemble the popular image of a deep, sleep-like trance.

What Does a Trance Feel Like?

Trance experiences can vary considerably from person to person.

Some people describe them as peaceful and relaxing, while others report intense concentration or a vivid sense of involvement in their thoughts and imagination.

In a hypnotic setting, possible experiences include:

  • Focused attention: Becoming more absorbed in the practitioner's voice, an image, or an internal experience.

  • Physical relaxation: Experiencing reduced muscle tension or a comfortable feeling of stillness.

  • Changes in time perception: Feeling that time has passed unusually quickly or slowly.

  • Mental imagery: Experiencing imagined scenes, sensations, or memories with varying degrees of vividness.

  • Reduced awareness of surroundings: Paying less attention to background sounds or other distractions.

  • Changes in perceived effort: Experiencing an imagined or suggested movement as happening more automatically.

  • Emotional responses: Experiencing feelings associated with particular suggestions, images, or memories.

These are possible experiences, not a checklist that everyone must satisfy.

Some people report a distinctly unusual experience during hypnosis, while others describe it as ordinary focused attention with a heightened ability to engage with suggestions.

Neither experience automatically indicates that hypnosis has succeeded or failed.

Research suggests that hypnotic suggestions can influence perception, cognition, behavior, and people's subjective sense of agency. However, the precise processes responsible for these effects remain the subject of scientific investigation.³

Is Trance an Altered State of Consciousness?

This is one of the most interesting questions in the study of hypnosis and trance.

An altered state of consciousness generally refers to a condition in which someone's subjective experience differs from their usual waking awareness.

Examples discussed in consciousness research include certain forms of meditation, dreaming, hypnosis, and other nonordinary experiences.

Many people use the expression altered state of consciousness to describe hypnotic trance.

However, there is disagreement about whether hypnosis requires a special or distinct state of consciousness.

Two broad perspectives have traditionally been central to this discussion: state theories and non-state theories.

Understanding these perspectives helps explain why opinions about trance differ so much.

What Is the State Theory of Hypnosis?

State theories propose that hypnosis involves a meaningful change in consciousness that is distinguishable from ordinary waking awareness.

According to this perspective, hypnotic trance is more than simply concentrating, relaxing, imagining, or following instructions.

Some state theorists suggest that hypnosis involves distinctive changes in cognitive functioning, awareness, or the organization of mental processes.

One influential example is Ernest Hilgard's neodissociation theory.

Hilgard proposed that hypnosis can involve divisions in awareness and control, allowing certain responses to occur without being fully integrated into a person's ordinary conscious experience.⁴

From this perspective, hypnotic trance can help explain experiences such as:

  • Feeling that a movement happens automatically.

  • Experiencing suggested sensations as unusually convincing.

  • Responding to suggestions without a strong sense of deliberate effort.

  • Experiencing changes in awareness or the perception of control.

It is important to understand that state theories are not all identical. Some propose a relatively distinctive altered state, while others describe more specific changes in attention, awareness, or cognitive processing.

The central idea is that something meaningful may change in the person's experience during hypnosis.

What Is the Non-State Theory of Hypnosis?

Non-state theories offer a different explanation.

Rather than requiring a special altered state of consciousness, they propose that hypnotic experiences can be understood through ordinary psychological processes.

These may include:

  • Attention.

  • Imagination.

  • Expectations.

  • Beliefs.

  • Motivation.

  • Social interaction.

  • Interpretation of suggestions.

  • Learned responses.

From this perspective, a person does not necessarily need to enter a special trance state to respond to hypnotic suggestions.

For example, someone who imagines their hand becoming lighter may experience an involuntary-feeling movement because of the interaction between expectation, imagination, attention, and motor processes.

The person may genuinely experience the movement as happening automatically, even though no special state of consciousness is required to explain it.

This perspective is particularly associated with sociocognitive approaches to hypnosis.

Researchers such as Irving Kirsch and Steven Jay Lynn have examined how expectations, beliefs, social context, and psychological processes contribute to hypnotic responses.⁵

Are State and Non-State Theories Completely Opposed?

Not necessarily.

Although the debate has sometimes been presented as a choice between two opposing explanations, contemporary research suggests that the distinction is more complicated.

Some researchers emphasize changes in consciousness, while others focus on ordinary psychological mechanisms. Other theoretical approaches incorporate elements of both.

A person can experience a genuine change in subjective awareness without researchers necessarily agreeing that this constitutes a unique or separate state of consciousness.

Similarly, explaining aspects of hypnosis through attention, expectation, and imagination does not mean that the experience is imaginary or deliberately fabricated.

A 2024 systematic review by Anoushiravan Zahedi, Steven Jay Lynn, and Werner Sommer examined prominent theories of hypnosis and found that different theoretical perspectives have their own strengths, limitations, and explanatory value. The authors emphasized that there is still no consensus about the mechanisms responsible for hypnotic responses.⁶

This is why it is more accurate to describe the nature of hypnotic trance as an ongoing scientific discussion rather than a question that has been definitively settled.

Why Do Opinions About Trance Differ?

There are several reasons why people have different opinions about trance.

One of the most important is that the word is used to describe different experiences in different contexts.

A neuroscientist studying brain activity during hypnosis may use the word differently from an anthropologist studying ritual practices or a hypnotherapist describing a client's experience.

Here are some of the main perspectives.

1. The Psychological Perspective

Psychologists are interested in how trance-like experiences relate to attention, perception, imagination, memory, emotion, and behavior.

Some psychologists view hypnotic trance as a distinctive psychological state, while others emphasize the influence of ordinary cognitive and social processes.

Psychological research also investigates individual differences in hypnotic suggestibility.

Some people respond strongly to particular hypnotic suggestions, while others respond less strongly. These differences can be studied using standardized hypnotizability measures.

From this perspective, trance is best understood by examining what people experience, how they respond to suggestions, and which psychological processes may explain those responses.

2. The Neuroscientific Perspective

Neuroscientists are interested in what happens in the brain during trance-like experiences.

Research into hypnosis has investigated brain activity and connectivity, particularly in networks associated with attention, executive control, and awareness.

Studies have identified associations between hypnotic responding and activity in areas including the anterior cingulate and prefrontal cortices.⁷

However, these findings should not be interpreted as evidence that there is one specific brain pattern that defines every kind of trance.

Different trance experiences may involve different psychological and neurological processes.

For example, hypnotic trance, meditative absorption, and rhythmic dance experiences should not automatically be assumed to produce identical changes in brain activity.

Researchers are continuing to investigate these differences.

3. The Hypnotherapy Perspective

Hypnotherapists often use the word trance to describe the focused condition in which therapeutic suggestions are introduced.

In this context, trance is generally considered useful because it provides an opportunity to work with attention, imagination, expectations, and responses to suggestion.

Different hypnotherapy traditions explain the process in different ways.

Some practitioners emphasize deep relaxation and altered awareness. Others focus more on communication, imagery, emotional associations, and the client's expectations.

For example, an Ericksonian hypnotherapist may use metaphors, stories, and indirect suggestions, while another practitioner may use a more structured induction involving relaxation and direct suggestions.

Some practitioners regard trance as an essential part of therapeutic hypnosis. Others use hypnotic communication without necessarily requiring a clearly identifiable trance experience.

These differences reflect the diversity of theoretical and practical approaches within hypnotherapy.

4. The Anthropological Perspective

Anthropologists study trance in relation to culture, society, rituals, and human experience.

In some cultural traditions, trance is associated with religious ceremonies, spiritual practices, healing rituals, or communication with supernatural beings.

Anthropologists are interested not only in what individuals experience but also in how those experiences are understood within their communities.

For example, an experience described as spirit possession in one cultural setting may be interpreted as a religious or spiritual event rather than a psychological phenomenon.

Anthropological approaches therefore encourage researchers to consider cultural meaning and social context rather than imposing a single explanation on every experience.

This is particularly important because beliefs about consciousness, identity, spirituality, and the body vary across cultures.

5. The Spiritual and Religious Perspective

Many spiritual and religious traditions include practices that involve trance-like experiences.

These may include:

  • Prayer and contemplation.

  • Chanting and repetitive vocalization.

  • Rhythmic movement and dance.

  • Meditation.

  • Ritual ceremonies.

  • Practices involving spiritual possession or altered awareness.

People participating in these practices may interpret their experiences in spiritual or religious terms.

For example, someone might describe a trance experience as feeling connected to a deity, receiving spiritual guidance, or experiencing a sense of unity with something greater than themselves.

These interpretations can be deeply meaningful to the people involved.

However, a scientific description of an experience and a person's spiritual interpretation of it are not necessarily the same thing. Science can investigate reported experiences, associated behavior, and possible neurological processes without necessarily establishing or disproving the spiritual explanations attached to them.

6. The Everyday Perspective

The word trance is also used informally to describe ordinary experiences of absorption.

For example:

  • Becoming so absorbed in a book that you lose track of time.

  • Listening to music and temporarily forgetting about your surroundings.

  • Driving a familiar route while your attention is focused elsewhere.

  • Becoming deeply involved in a creative activity.

  • Daydreaming while looking out of a window.

These experiences are sometimes described as everyday trance or trance-like absorption.

However, everyday absorption should not automatically be equated with hypnotic trance. The similarities and differences depend on how the experiences are defined and measured.

What Is the Difference Between Hypnotic Trance, Meditation, and Daydreaming?

These experiences can sometimes appear similar because they may involve focused attention, changes in awareness, and reduced attention to external distractions.

Nevertheless, they have different characteristics and purposes.

Experience

Main characteristics

Typical context

Hypnotic trance

Focused attention and responsiveness to hypnotic suggestions

Hypnosis and hypnotherapy

Meditation

Practices involving attention, awareness, or contemplation

Personal practice and spiritual traditions

Daydreaming

Spontaneous or loosely directed internal thought and imagery

Everyday life

Flow

Deep involvement in an activity, often with sustained concentration

Sports, creativity, and skilled activities

Religious trance

Experiences interpreted within a religious or spiritual framework

Rituals and ceremonies

Rhythmic or dance trance

Experiences associated with movement, rhythm, and music

Dance and cultural practices

There can be overlap between these experiences, and researchers sometimes investigate shared features.

For example, both meditation and hypnosis can involve changes in attention and subjective awareness. However, they are not identical procedures, and findings from research into one should not automatically be applied to the other.

Is Flow a Type of Trance?

The concept of flow is particularly interesting because it shares some characteristics with trance-like absorption.

Psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi developed the concept of flow to describe a condition of deep involvement in an activity.

People experiencing flow may report:

  • Strong concentration.

  • Reduced awareness of distractions.

  • A sense of involvement in the activity.

  • Changes in their perception of time.

  • A feeling that their actions are progressing smoothly.

For example, a musician might become so involved in performing that they pay little attention to anything outside the music.

Although flow and trance can share characteristics, flow is a distinct psychological concept and should not automatically be treated as a form of hypnosis.

What Is a Religious or Spiritual Trance?

Religious and spiritual trance experiences have been documented in many cultural and historical settings.

They can involve changes in awareness, identity, emotional experience, bodily sensations, or the perceived relationship between the individual and the surrounding world.

Some examples include:

Possession trance: An experience in which a person or community interprets changes in behavior or identity as the presence or influence of a spirit, deity, or other supernatural being.

Ecstatic trance: An experience often described in terms of intense emotion, spiritual connection, or a sense of transcendence.

Ritual trance: An experience occurring within a structured cultural or religious ceremony, sometimes involving music, chanting, movement, or repetitive activity.

Shamanic trance: Experiences associated with certain shamanic traditions, sometimes involving altered awareness and culturally specific interpretations of spiritual journeys or communication.

These categories are broad descriptive terms, and their meanings differ between traditions.

Researchers studying such experiences may investigate the roles of rhythm, expectation, social participation, cultural beliefs, and individual experience.

It is important not to assume that every religious trance experience has the same cause or psychological meaning.

Nor should culturally meaningful experiences automatically be classified as symptoms of mental illness simply because they differ from ordinary waking experience.

Can Trance Occur Without Hypnosis?

Yes.

A formal hypnotic induction is not required for every experience described as trance.

People can experience deep absorption or altered awareness during various activities, including:

  • Listening to music.

  • Dancing.

  • Meditation.

  • Repetitive movement.

  • Prayer.

  • Creative activities.

  • Intense concentration.

  • Certain ritual practices.

The term trance is therefore broader than formal hypnosis.

However, researchers and clinicians need to be precise about the context. A trance-like experience during a dance ceremony is not necessarily the same phenomenon as a hypnotic experience produced through a structured induction and suggestions.

This distinction is particularly important when comparing research studies.

Does Everyone Experience Trance in the Same Way?

No. Individual experiences can vary considerably.

Some people describe trance as a deeply relaxing experience. Others report heightened concentration, vivid imagery, unusual bodily sensations, or a feeling that their responses are happening automatically.

Some people may experience noticeable changes in awareness, while others describe relatively subtle changes.

Individual differences can be influenced by several factors, including:

  • Expectations: What someone believes will happen can influence how they interpret the experience.

  • Attention: The ability to focus on a particular activity or suggestion may influence the experience.

  • Imagination: Mental imagery can contribute to some hypnotic and trance-like experiences.

  • Motivation: A person's interest and willingness to participate can affect their engagement.

  • Experience: Previous exposure to hypnosis, meditation, or other practices may influence expectations and familiarity.

  • Cultural context: Beliefs and shared interpretations can shape how experiences are understood.

These factors do not necessarily explain every trance experience, but they are important considerations in psychological research.

Research into hypnotic suggestibility also indicates that people differ in their responsiveness to standardized hypnotic suggestions.⁸

Can Someone Be in a Trance Without Knowing It?

This question depends on how the word trance is being used.

In everyday conversation, someone might say that a person is in a trance because they appear completely absorbed in an activity.

For example, someone watching an engaging performance might be so focused that they pay little attention to their surroundings.

In hypnosis, people may also experience responses as automatic or involuntary, without feeling that they are deliberately producing them.

However, this does not mean that people are necessarily unconscious or unaware of what is happening.

The popular idea that someone can unknowingly be placed into a deep hypnotic trance and then controlled without their awareness is not an accurate general description of hypnosis.

A person may not use the word trance to describe their experience, even when someone else considers their behavior trance-like.

This is another reason why researchers need clear definitions rather than relying solely on appearances.

Does Being in a Trance Mean Losing Control?

No. A trance experience does not automatically mean losing control of yourself.

This is one of the most persistent misconceptions about hypnosis.

People sometimes imagine that trance involves becoming completely passive, unconscious, or unable to make decisions.

In reality, hypnotic experiences vary, and people generally remain capable of responding to their surroundings and communicating during hypnosis.

Some individuals may experience suggested actions as involuntary, but this subjective feeling does not mean that they have surrendered all personal agency.

The experience of reduced control over a particular response is different from losing the ability to make decisions altogether.

Similarly, a person experiencing a spiritual or ritual trance may interpret changes in their behavior differently depending on their cultural and religious framework.

It is therefore important to distinguish between the subjective feeling of involuntariness, observable behavior, and actual loss of control.

Is Trance the Same as Sleep?

No.

Although some trance experiences involve relaxation and reduced awareness of external surroundings, trance and sleep are different concepts.

Sleep is a biological condition involving characteristic changes in brain activity, responsiveness, and physiological functioning.

Hypnotic trance, by contrast, generally involves focused attention and responsiveness to suggestions.

A person undergoing hypnosis may appear relaxed, have their eyes closed, and remain relatively still. However, these features do not mean that they are asleep.

Some people experience hypnosis while sitting comfortably with their eyes open.

The distinction is important because hypnosis is not simply a process of putting someone to sleep.

Can You Enter a Trance Through Music or Repetition?

Music and repetitive activities can contribute to trance-like experiences for some people.

Rhythm, repetition, and sustained attention can influence how someone experiences an activity.

Examples include:

  • Repetitive drumming.

  • Chanting.

  • Rhythmic dancing.

  • Repetitive musical patterns.

  • Repeated breathing exercises.

  • Certain meditative practices.

Research into trance experiences has explored how rhythmic stimulation, cultural practices, and other environmental factors may contribute to changes in subjective experience.⁹

However, music or repetition does not automatically produce a trance.

The effect depends on the person, the activity, the context, and the meaning attached to the experience.

What Happens in the Brain During Trance?

This is an active area of research.

Scientists use techniques such as electroencephalography (EEG), functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), and other neuroimaging methods to investigate changes associated with hypnosis and different trance-like experiences.

In hypnosis research, scientists have examined brain networks involved in:

  • Attention and concentration.

  • Executive control.

  • Self-awareness.

  • Perception.

  • Cognitive processing.

  • The experience of agency.

Some studies have reported changes involving the anterior cingulate cortex and prefrontal regions during hypnotic responding.

These findings are interesting because they suggest that hypnotic experiences involve measurable changes in brain functioning.

However, there is no single universally accepted neurological signature that identifies every form of trance.

Different experiences may involve different patterns of brain activity, and interpreting these findings requires care.

A 2024 review by Olivia Gosseries and colleagues examined the phenomenology, brain correlates, and potential clinical applications of different trance experiences. The authors emphasized the diversity of trance phenomena and the need for more research combining subjective reports with neurophysiological measurements.¹⁰

This is an important reminder that the scientific understanding of trance is still developing.

Is Trance Dangerous?

Most everyday experiences of absorption, such as becoming engrossed in music or a book, are not inherently dangerous.

Hypnotic experiences conducted appropriately are also generally considered low risk. Nevertheless, not every experience described as trance is necessarily harmless or appropriate in every circumstance.

Some people may experience temporary emotional discomfort, anxiety, or distress during certain practices.

More intense experiences involving dissociation, traumatic memories, or unusual perceptions deserve particular care.

It is important to distinguish between:

  • Voluntary, culturally accepted trance experiences.

  • Hypnotic experiences conducted in an appropriate therapeutic setting.

  • Unwanted or distressing changes in awareness.

  • Experiences associated with medical or psychological difficulties.

An unusual experience is not automatically a sign of illness. However, if someone experiences recurring episodes of lost awareness, unexplained memory gaps, significant distress, or difficulty functioning, it is sensible to seek an appropriate medical or mental health assessment.

Trance should not be used as a substitute for professional evaluation when someone has concerning symptoms.

Can Trance Be Used Therapeutically?

Yes. Hypnotic trance and other forms of focused attention have been investigated in a variety of clinical contexts.

Clinical hypnosis is used as an intervention or complementary technique in some healthcare settings.

Research has examined applications involving:

  • Pain management.

  • Anxiety associated with medical procedures.

  • Irritable bowel syndrome.

  • Stress management.

  • Certain symptoms associated with medical treatment.

However, the strength of the evidence varies according to the condition, intervention, and research methodology.

It is also important to distinguish clinical hypnosis from other practices described as trance. Evidence supporting a particular hypnotic intervention does not automatically demonstrate the effectiveness of religious, ritual, or other trance-induction practices.

For therapeutic use, the most appropriate approach is one that has a clear rationale, realistic objectives, and evidence relevant to the problem being addressed.

Why Do Some Hypnotherapists Avoid the Word "Trance"?

Interestingly, not all hypnotherapists and researchers are comfortable with the term trance.

Some prefer to describe hypnosis in terms of focused attention, imagination, suggestion, and responsiveness rather than suggesting that a person enters a special altered state.

There are several reasons for this preference.

The term can be misleading. Some people associate trance with unconsciousness, sleep, or a loss of control.

It can create unrealistic expectations. Clients may believe they need to experience something dramatic or unusual for hypnosis to work.

It has multiple meanings. The word can refer to hypnotic experiences, spiritual practices, everyday absorption, or other conditions.

It can imply a theoretical explanation. Describing hypnosis as a trance may suggest that a special state of consciousness has been established, even though this remains debated.

In his 2024 review of hypnosis in psychotherapy and medicine, Burkhard Peter discusses the different ways the term is used and explains why some English-language hypnosis researchers and practitioners prefer more specific terminology.¹¹

This does not mean that the word should never be used. Rather, it is helpful to explain what kind of experience is being discussed.

What Is the Difference Between Trance and Dissociation?

Trance and dissociation are sometimes discussed together, but they are not synonymous.

Trance is a broad term used to describe experiences involving absorption, focused attention, or changes in awareness.

Dissociation refers to disruptions or separations in the usual integration of aspects of consciousness, memory, identity, perception, or experience.

Some theories of hypnosis propose that certain hypnotic responses involve dissociative processes.

For example, Hilgard's neodissociation theory suggests that hypnosis can involve divisions in awareness and control.

However, not every trance-like experience involves clinically significant dissociation, and not every dissociative experience is a trance.

The distinction is especially important in healthcare because dissociation can occur in several different psychological and clinical contexts.

It would therefore be misleading to assume that someone who experiences a hypnotic trance has a dissociative disorder.

Can Trance Be Self-Induced?

Yes. People can deliberately engage in practices intended to produce trance-like experiences without another person guiding them.

Examples include:

  • Self-hypnosis.

  • Meditation.

  • Guided visualization.

  • Repetitive breathing exercises.

  • Focused attention practices.

  • Certain forms of rhythmic movement.

Self-hypnosis is particularly relevant because it uses techniques similar to those found in guided hypnosis, but the individual directs the process themselves.

A simple self-hypnosis exercise might involve sitting comfortably, focusing attention on breathing, relaxing the body, and using constructive suggestions or mental imagery.

Not everyone experiences the same degree of absorption, and there is no requirement to achieve a particular sensation.

For anyone exploring self-hypnosis, it is sensible to practice in a safe, comfortable environment rather than while driving or performing activities requiring full attention.

What Are Some Common Myths About Trance?

Popular entertainment and sensational descriptions have contributed to several misconceptions.

Here are some important distinctions.

Myth

A more accurate explanation

Trance means being unconscious.

Many trance-like experiences occur while someone remains conscious and responsive.

Everyone experiences trance in the same way.

Experiences vary considerably between individuals and contexts.

Trance is always hypnosis.

Trance is a broader term encompassing many different experiences.

A person in trance loses all control.

Hypnotic responses can feel involuntary without implying a complete loss of agency.

Trance is necessarily supernatural.

Experiences can be studied psychologically and neurologically, although spiritual interpretations may also be meaningful to participants.

There is one specific brain pattern for all trance.

Different experiences may involve different neurological processes.

Trance requires deep relaxation.

Some forms involve relaxation, while others involve movement, concentration, or intense emotional engagement.

Anyone can be forced into any trance.

Experiences depend on individual and contextual factors, and there is no reliable basis for claims of unlimited control.

How Should We Understand Trance Today?

Perhaps the most useful way to understand trance is to recognize that it is an umbrella term rather than a single, precisely defined experience.

From a psychological perspective, it can involve changes in attention, imagination, perception, and subjective experience.

From a neuroscientific perspective, it provides an opportunity to investigate how different patterns of awareness and responsiveness relate to brain functioning.

From a hypnotherapy perspective, it often describes a focused condition in which therapeutic suggestions are introduced.

From an anthropological and spiritual perspective, it can describe experiences with important cultural, religious, and personal meanings.

These perspectives do not always offer the same explanations, and that is precisely why the subject is so interesting.

The scientific debate about hypnotic trance also reminds us that describing an experience and explaining its underlying mechanisms are two different things.

Researchers can investigate what people experience, how their behavior changes, and which brain processes are involved without necessarily agreeing on whether trance represents a special state of consciousness.

As research develops, our understanding of these experiences will become more detailed.

Final Thoughts: Is Trance a State of Mind or a Way of Describing an Experience?

Trance can be understood in several ways, depending on the context in which the word is used.

For some people, it describes a distinctive altered state of consciousness. For others, particularly those who favor sociocognitive explanations of hypnosis, it is better understood through ordinary psychological processes such as attention, imagination, expectation, and suggestion.

For spiritual practitioners and members of different cultural traditions, trance may have religious or personal significance that goes beyond a purely psychological description.

There is no need to assume that all these perspectives describe precisely the same phenomenon.

What matters is being clear about the experience under discussion and distinguishing personal interpretations from scientific explanations.

The study of trance brings together psychology, neuroscience, hypnotherapy, anthropology, and consciousness research. It offers fascinating opportunities to explore how people experience attention, awareness, imagination, and their relationship with the world around them.

Ultimately, keeping an open mind while remaining evidence-conscious is the best way to approach this intriguing subject.

Notes

1. Anoushiravan Zahedi, Steven Jay Lynn, and Werner Sommer, "How Hypnotic Suggestions Work: A Systematic Review of Prominent Theories of Hypnosis," Consciousness and Cognition 123 (August 2024): 103730.

2. Burkhard Peter, "Hypnosis in Psychotherapy, Psychosomatics and Medicine: A Brief Overview," Frontiers in Psychology 15 (2024): 1377900.

3. Zahedi, Lynn, and Sommer, "How Hypnotic Suggestions Work."

4. Ernest R. Hilgard, Divided Consciousness: Multiple Controls in Human Thought and Action (New York: Wiley, 1977).

5. Irving Kirsch and Steven Jay Lynn, "The Altered State of Hypnosis: Changes in the Theoretical Landscape," American Psychologist 50, no. 10 (1995): 846–58.

6. Zahedi, Lynn, and Sommer, "How Hypnotic Suggestions Work."

7. Mark P. Jensen et al., "New Directions in Hypnosis Research: Strategies for Advancing the Cognitive and Clinical Neuroscience of Hypnosis," Neuroscience of Consciousness 2017, no. 1 (2017): nix004.

8. David J. Acunzo and Devin B. Terhune, "A Critical Review of Standardized Measures of Hypnotic Suggestibility," International Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis 69, no. 1 (2021): 50–71.

9. Olivia Gosseries et al., "Exploration of Trance States: Phenomenology, Brain Correlates, and Clinical Applications," Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences 58 (2024): 101400.

10. Gosseries et al., "Exploration of Trance States."

11. Peter, "Hypnosis in Psychotherapy, Psychosomatics and Medicine."


Was this article helpful?