# What is "EMDR" an can it be combined with hypnotherapy?

Source: https://faq.hypnotechs.com/miscellaneous/what-is-emdr-an-can-it-be-combined-with-hypnotherapy

EMDR is a psychological therapy that has attracted considerable attention for its use in treating trauma and other forms of psychological distress. Although the name may sound a little unusual, the approach is well established in the field of psychotherapy and is recommended in several clinical guidelines for the treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

The initials stand for **Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing**. EMDR involves recalling distressing experiences while simultaneously engaging in a form of bilateral stimulation, most commonly guided eye movements. The aim is to help people process disturbing memories so that they become less emotionally overwhelming.

But what exactly happens during EMDR? Why are eye movements involved? Does it work through hypnosis? And, perhaps most interestingly, can EMDR and hypnotherapy be combined?

The short answer to the last question is yes, they can potentially be used within the same broader treatment plan. However, combining them requires appropriate clinical judgment, and there is a difference between using two approaches at different points in treatment and blending their techniques into a single procedure.

Both EMDR and hypnosis involve attention, imagery, and subjective experience, so there are some interesting areas of overlap. Nevertheless, they are distinct approaches with different histories, procedures, and theoretical explanations.

Let's explore what EMDR involves, what the research tells us, and how it might relate to hypnotherapy.

## What Does EMDR Stand For?

EMDR stands for Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing.

It was developed by American psychologist Francine Shapiro in the late 1980s. Shapiro initially explored the effects of eye movements on disturbing thoughts and memories, eventually developing a structured therapeutic approach that became known as EMDR.¹

The name describes two central ideas:

- Desensitization: Reducing the emotional distress associated with disturbing memories or experiences.
- Reprocessing: Helping the person develop a different, less distressing way of experiencing and understanding those memories.

The word reprocessing is particularly important. EMDR is not intended to erase memories or make someone forget what happened to them. Instead, the goal is to help the person remember an experience without being overwhelmed by the emotions and reactions that previously accompanied it.

For example, someone who experienced a frightening accident might continue to feel intense anxiety whenever they hear a particular sound associated with the event.

Although the accident is in the past, the memory may still feel emotionally immediate.

EMDR aims to help the individual process the memory so that it can increasingly be experienced as something that happened in the past rather than something that is still happening.

## How Does EMDR Work?

EMDR uses a structured approach in which a person focuses on aspects of a distressing memory while simultaneously engaging in bilateral stimulation.

Bilateral stimulation means alternating stimulation between the left and right sides of the body or sensory system.

The most familiar form involves following a therapist's moving fingers or another visual target with the eyes. Other methods may include alternating sounds delivered through headphones or gentle alternating tactile stimulation, such as tapping.

A typical EMDR exercise might involve the following:

1. The person identifies a distressing memory or experience.
2. They bring to mind an image or aspect of the memory.
3. They identify associated emotions, physical sensations, and negative beliefs about themselves.
4. They focus on the memory while following a series of guided eye movements or another form of bilateral stimulation.
5. They briefly pause to notice what thoughts, images, emotions, or sensations arise.
6. The process is repeated as the therapist guides the session.

The therapist does not simply ask the person to relive a traumatic experience repeatedly without direction. EMDR is a structured treatment that includes preparation, assessment, processing, and review.

The process is intended to help the person develop a less distressing relationship with the memory.

It is worth emphasizing that EMDR does not require the person to explain every detail of a traumatic experience aloud. Depending on the treatment and the individual's circumstances, much of the processing can take place internally.

## Why Does EMDR Use Eye Movements?

This is one of the most frequently asked questions about EMDR.

Why should moving the eyes from side to side while thinking about a disturbing memory make any difference?

The precise explanation remains a subject of scientific investigation.

One influential theory is that the working memory system plays an important role.

Working memory is the limited mental capacity we use to hold and manipulate information temporarily. When someone recalls a distressing memory while simultaneously performing another demanding task, the two activities may compete for available working memory resources.

As a result, the recalled memory may become less vivid or emotionally intense.

Research by Andrew R. Lee and Chris R. Brewin, among others, has examined the effects of eye movements on the vividness and emotional intensity of memories. Such findings provide support for the possibility that eye movements can influence the experience of recalled memories.²

However, this does not establish that working memory competition explains every aspect of EMDR or that eye movements alone account for the therapy's effectiveness.

Other explanations have also been proposed, including changes in attention, physiological arousal, and memory processing.

The important distinction is that EMDR is a complete therapeutic approach, not simply an eye-movement exercise.

## What Is EMDR Used For?

EMDR is best known for its application in treating post-traumatic stress disorder.

PTSD can develop after someone experiences or witnesses a traumatic event. Symptoms may include:

- Intrusive memories or unwanted recollections.
- Distressing dreams or nightmares.
- Avoidance of reminders of the event.
- Persistent feelings of fear or threat.
- Increased alertness or being easily startled.
- Negative changes in mood and beliefs.
- Difficulties with sleep and concentration.

A person with PTSD may find that reminders of a traumatic experience produce emotional or physical reactions that seem disproportionate to the present situation.

For example, someone who experienced a serious car accident might feel intense anxiety when traveling in a vehicle, even when there is no immediate danger.

EMDR aims to help process the memories contributing to these reactions.

It has also been investigated for other conditions, including anxiety, depression, and certain forms of complicated grief. However, the strength of the evidence differs between conditions, and its best-established clinical application is PTSD.

The American Psychological Association, the World Health Organization, and the Department of Veterans Affairs and Department of Defense have included EMDR among the psychological treatments recommended for PTSD, although recommendations and treatment preferences differ between guidelines.³

## Does EMDR Really Work?

There is substantial clinical research supporting EMDR as a treatment for PTSD.

Randomized controlled trials and systematic reviews have found that EMDR can reduce PTSD symptoms, and several clinical guidelines recognize it as an evidence-based treatment option.

For example, the World Health Organization's guidelines for managing conditions specifically related to stress include EMDR among the psychological interventions that may be offered to adults with PTSD.³

The Department of Veterans Affairs and Department of Defense also recommend EMDR among the trauma-focused psychotherapies for PTSD in their clinical practice guideline.³

However, it is important not to interpret these recommendations as evidence that EMDR works equally well for everyone.

Some people experience substantial improvements, while others may require a different treatment approach, additional support, or a combination of interventions.

There is also ongoing scientific discussion about which components of EMDR contribute most to its effectiveness.

The evidence that EMDR can help with PTSD is considerably stronger than the evidence for some of the proposed explanations of exactly how it works.

That distinction is important: a treatment can demonstrate clinical effectiveness even when researchers are still investigating its underlying mechanisms.

## Is EMDR a Form of Hypnosis?

No. EMDR and hypnosis are distinct therapeutic approaches, although they share some features.

Both may involve focused attention, imagery, and changes in how a person experiences thoughts, feelings, and memories. Both can also involve guided instructions from a therapist.

However, EMDR does not require the person to enter a hypnotic state, and a therapist can conduct EMDR without using hypnosis.

Similarly, hypnosis does not require eye movements or the specific procedures associated with EMDR.

One difference is that EMDR follows a structured treatment protocol that includes preparation, assessment, memory processing, and evaluation. Hypnotherapy is a broader category of interventions that use hypnosis for different purposes.

Hypnosis may be used to support relaxation, imagery, behavioral change, or therapeutic exploration. EMDR has a more specific clinical history and is particularly associated with trauma-focused treatment.

It is therefore misleading to describe EMDR as simply another form of hypnosis.

## Can EMDR and Hypnotherapy Be Combined?

Yes. EMDR and hypnotherapy can be used within the same overall treatment plan, and published clinical literature has discussed ways of integrating elements of the two approaches.

The important qualification is that the combination has a more limited evidence base than EMDR alone for treating PTSD.

Some clinicians have explored using hypnosis to help clients prepare for EMDR, manage distress during treatment, or develop psychological resources that may be useful during trauma processing.

For example, a therapist might use a carefully structured hypnotic exercise to help a client practice relaxation or imagine a place associated with safety and stability before beginning EMDR.

The therapist might then use the established EMDR protocol when the client is ready to work on a distressing memory.

Other approaches have attempted to integrate hypnotic procedures and bilateral eye movements more directly. Published discussions of these methods include clinical reports and conceptual papers, but these do not establish that combined treatment is more effective than EMDR alone.⁴

The distinction between possible and proven is important here.

The fact that two therapies can be combined does not automatically mean that combining them improves outcomes. A combined approach needs to be selected for a sound clinical reason, with attention to the individual's needs, preferences, and ability to manage the treatment.

## Why Might a Therapist Combine EMDR and Hypnotherapy?

There are several reasons a qualified clinician might consider using both approaches.

Preparation for trauma processing

Some people find it difficult to approach distressing memories because the associated emotions feel overwhelming. Hypnosis may provide an opportunity to practice relaxation, attention regulation, or other coping strategies before beginning trauma-focused work.

Developing coping resources

Hypnotic imagery may help some clients practice skills for managing distress between sessions. For example, a therapist might guide a client through an imagery exercise designed to help them recall a sense of calm or personal strength.

Supporting emotional regulation

A clinician may use hypnosis to help a client recognize and manage emotional reactions, provided the technique is appropriate for that person and does not become a way of unnecessarily avoiding the therapeutic work.

Addressing individual treatment needs

People respond differently to psychological interventions. A clinician may consider integrating techniques when there is a clear rationale for doing so and the treatment remains consistent with the client's goals.

These are potential reasons to consider integration, not guarantees of benefit. A therapist should be able to explain why the combination is appropriate and how progress will be evaluated.

## What Does the Research Say About Combining EMDR and Hypnosis?

There is published literature specifically addressing this combination, but the evidence needs to be interpreted in context.

In 2001, H. E. Hollander and S. S. Bender published an article in the American Journal of Clinical Hypnosis describing an approach called Eye Closure, Eye Movements, which integrated elements of hypnosis and eye movements in trauma treatment. The article discussed the clinical rationale and illustrated the approach, but it was not a large randomized controlled trial establishing its effectiveness.⁴

That same year, D. B. Beere, M. J. Simon, and K. Welch published a paper offering recommendations and clinical illustrations for combining hypnosis and EMDR. Their discussion drew on clinical experience and a series of cases, suggesting that hypnosis might sometimes help clients prepare for EMDR or manage difficult emotional experiences during treatment.⁵

A later case-control study published in Clinical Rheumatology in 2020 investigated a treatment program that combined individual hypnosis and EMDR for trauma-related difficulties, followed by supportive-expressive group therapy. The study reported improvements in psychological distress and quality of life among the treatment group. However, the program involved multiple components, and the design does not establish that combining hypnosis with EMDR was responsible for the improvements or that the combination is superior to EMDR alone.⁶

Taken together, these publications show that clinicians have explored integration and reported potentially useful applications.

They do not establish a definitive answer about which combination is best, which clients benefit most, or whether integrated treatment produces better outcomes than established treatments delivered separately.

For PTSD, EMDR remains a treatment with substantial evidence supporting its use. The evidence for adding hypnotherapy specifically to improve EMDR outcomes is much more limited.

## Could Hypnosis Make EMDR More Effective?

It is possible that hypnosis could help some individuals engage with particular aspects of therapy, but there is not enough evidence to conclude that it generally makes EMDR more effective.

For example, hypnosis might help a person practice emotional regulation before confronting a distressing memory. If that preparation makes the person better able to participate in treatment, it could be useful.

However, additional techniques are not always better. A client may respond well to standard EMDR without needing hypnosis, while another person may find a particular hypnotic exercise distracting or uncomfortable.

Adding techniques can also make it more difficult to determine which part of a treatment is responsible for improvement.

A responsible clinician should therefore avoid presenting combined EMDR and hypnotherapy as a superior treatment simply because it incorporates two approaches.

The relevant question is whether the combination has a clear purpose for the individual and whether the available evidence supports the proposed use.

## Can Hypnotherapy Be Used Before EMDR?

Yes, in some circumstances.

A therapist might use hypnosis before EMDR to help a client practice grounding, relaxation, or imagery-based coping skills. This may be particularly relevant when the client needs help developing ways to manage distress during trauma-focused work.

However, preparation should be tailored to the person rather than treated as a mandatory hypnotic step.

EMDR already includes preparation as part of its standard treatment structure. This may involve discussing expectations, identifying coping strategies, and helping the client understand how the process works.

Some clients will need little additional preparation, while others may benefit from more time developing the skills needed to participate comfortably.

Hypnosis is one possible option, not a prerequisite for successful EMDR.

It is also important that preparation supports the client's ability to engage with treatment rather than becoming an indefinite way to postpone it without a clinical reason.

## Can Hypnotherapy Be Used After EMDR?

It may be appropriate in some cases, depending on the person's needs and the treatment plan.

For example, a therapist might use hypnosis to help a client practice relaxation, strengthen a sense of confidence, or work toward a separate therapeutic goal after an EMDR session.

However, clinicians should consider the timing and intensity of any additional intervention.

EMDR sessions can bring up strong emotions, memories, or physical sensations. Some people feel tired or emotionally unsettled afterward, while others experience relief.

Adding another intensive technique immediately after trauma processing may not be helpful for everyone.

The therapist should assess how the client is responding and prioritize appropriate closure, emotional stability, and a plan for managing any distress between sessions.

More treatment within a single session does not necessarily mean better treatment.

## Is It Safe to Combine EMDR and Hypnotherapy?

The safety of a combined approach depends on the individual, the techniques used, the therapist's competence, and the way treatment is paced.

Both EMDR and hypnotherapy can involve focusing attention on emotionally significant material. For someone processing trauma, this may temporarily increase distress.

Some clients may also have difficulties with dissociation, emotional regulation, or feeling overwhelmed when recalling certain experiences. These factors require careful assessment and an individualized treatment plan.

A clinician who uses both approaches should be appropriately trained in each, understand the relevant risks, and know when to slow down, modify, or stop an exercise.

It is particularly important not to assume that hypnosis is automatically calming or that it will prevent distress during EMDR.

Nor should hypnosis be used to encourage the creation of supposedly recovered memories or to treat imagined memories as proof of historical events. Memory is reconstructive, and therapeutic suggestions can influence how people interpret and report their experiences.

If a person experiences significant distress, worsening symptoms, or difficulties functioning after treatment, they should discuss this with their clinician promptly.

## Is It Better to Choose EMDR, Hypnotherapy, or Both?

There is no single answer that applies to everyone.

The choice should depend on the problem being treated, the quality of the evidence for the proposed intervention, the individual's preferences, and the qualifications of the practitioner.

For someone with PTSD, EMDR is one of the trauma-focused psychotherapies recommended by major clinical guidelines. Other evidence-based options include cognitive processing therapy and prolonged exposure.³

Hypnotherapy may be useful for certain goals, but its evidence base varies according to the condition and the technique being used.

Combining EMDR and hypnosis may be worth considering when a clinician can explain a specific reason for doing so. It should not be assumed that combining them is automatically more effective than choosing one well-supported treatment.

If you are considering both, useful questions to ask a practitioner include:

- What is the specific purpose of combining these approaches in my case?
- What evidence supports the proposed treatment?
- What training and qualifications do you have in EMDR and clinical hypnosis?
- How will we assess whether the treatment is helping?
- What will we do if the process becomes overwhelming?
- Are there alternatives with stronger evidence for my particular concern?

You deserve clear answers and a treatment plan that takes your preferences, safety, and goals seriously.

## What Should You Look for in a Qualified Practitioner?

If you are interested in EMDR, hypnotherapy, or a combination of the two, choosing an appropriately trained professional is an important first step.

Look for a practitioner who:

- Has appropriate professional qualifications and experience for your needs.
- Has specific training in EMDR if they propose to provide EMDR therapy.
- Has suitable training in clinical hypnosis if they propose to use hypnotherapy.
- Explains the purpose, benefits, limitations, and potential risks of the proposed approach.
- Respects your right to ask questions, decline a technique, or stop treatment.
- Can explain how progress will be assessed and when a different approach might be appropriate.

For significant trauma-related symptoms, consider a licensed mental health professional with appropriate training in trauma treatment. You can ask whether they follow an established EMDR protocol and whether hypnosis is genuinely necessary for your treatment goals.

Be cautious of anyone who promises to erase traumatic memories, guarantee recovery, or claims that combining therapies will produce dramatically better results without adequate evidence.

The goal is not to find the practitioner who offers the greatest number of techniques. It is to find someone who can explain why a particular approach makes sense for you.

## What Is the Main Difference Between EMDR and Hypnotherapy?

The central difference is that EMDR is a specific, structured psychotherapy, whereas hypnotherapy is a broader category of approaches that use hypnosis for therapeutic purposes.

EMDR has substantial research support for treating PTSD and is recommended in major clinical practice guidelines. Hypnotherapy may be used for a variety of goals, but the strength of evidence depends on the condition and the intervention.

The two approaches can overlap in their use of focused attention, imagery, and guided therapeutic exercises. Clinicians have also developed methods that combine elements of both.

Nevertheless, they are not interchangeable, and there is not enough evidence to conclude that combining them is generally better than using an established treatment on its own.

If you are considering EMDR and hypnotherapy, the most useful starting point is to identify your treatment goal and discuss the available evidence with a qualified practitioner.

## Final Thoughts

EMDR is a structured psychological treatment with substantial evidence supporting its use for PTSD. Hypnotherapy is a separate approach that may help with certain therapeutic goals, depending on the individual and the techniques used.

Combining the two is possible, and clinical literature describes several ways practitioners have attempted to integrate them. Hypnosis may sometimes support preparation, emotional regulation, or other aspects of treatment.

However, promising clinical examples are not the same as strong evidence that an integrated approach is more effective than EMDR alone.

The most sensible approach is to select treatment based on your needs, the quality of the evidence, and the expertise of the clinician. A thoughtful combination may be appropriate in some cases, but it should have a clear clinical rationale rather than being assumed to be better simply because it involves more techniques.

## Notes

1\. Francine Shapiro, “Efficacy of the Eye Movement Desensitization Procedure in the Treatment of Traumatic Memories,” Journal of Traumatic Stress 2, no. 2 (1989): 199–223.

2\. Christopher W. Lee and Pim Cuijpers, “A Meta-Analysis of the Contribution of Eye Movements in Processing Emotional Memories,” Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 44, no. 2 (2013): 231–239.

3\. Department of Veterans Affairs and Department of Defense, VA/DoD Clinical Practice Guideline for the Management of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder and Acute Stress Disorder (2023); World Health Organization, Guidelines for the Management of Conditions Specifically Related to Stress (Geneva: World Health Organization, 2013).

4\. H. E. Hollander and S. S. Bender, “ECEM (Eye Closure Eye Movements): Integrating Aspects of EMDR with Hypnosis for Treatment of Trauma,” American Journal of Clinical Hypnosis 43, nos. 3–4 (2001): 187–202.

5\. D. B. Beere, M. J. Simon, and K. Welch, “Recommendations and Illustrations for Combining Hypnosis and EMDR in the Treatment of Psychological Trauma,” American Journal of Clinical Hypnosis 43, nos. 3–4 (2001): 217–231.

6\. Maria Teresa Corsetti et al., “Psychological Distress and Quality of Life Are Improved in Autoimmune Patients through Tandem-Psychotherapy, Combining Individual Hypnosis and Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) Treatment for Trauma, Followed by Supportive-Expressive Group Therapy,” Clinical Rheumatology 39, no. 4 (2020): 1331–1339.
