I can't be hypnotized...

When someone says, “I can’t be hypnotized,” the best response is usually calm, respectful, and curious:

“That’s okay. Hypnosis is not something you have to force. We can talk about what you expect, what concerns you, and whether this approach feels right for you.”

This response avoids an argument and keeps the conversation collaborative. It also recognizes an important point: hypnosis is not a test of intelligence, willpower, or personal worth. People differ in how they respond to hypnotic suggestions, and a person’s expectations, motivation, attention, and willingness to participate can all matter.¹

Is it helpful to tell the person that everyone can be hypnotized?

Usually, no. Saying “Everyone can be hypnotized” may sound reassuring, but it can also feel dismissive—especially if the person has tried hypnosis before and did not experience what they expected.

A more accurate response is:

“People vary in how responsive they are to hypnotic suggestions. You do not need to prove anything, and we can find out whether it is useful for you.”

Research generally treats hypnotic responsiveness as a measurable individual difference rather than an all-or-nothing ability.² Some people respond strongly to suggestions, some respond moderately, and some respond only to certain types of suggestions or under certain conditions.³

That variation does not mean that one person is “good” at hypnosis and another is “bad” at it. It simply means that people experience suggested changes differently.

What if the person says, “I’m too strong-minded”?

You might say:

“Being thoughtful and independent does not prevent you from participating in hypnosis. You remain able to think, evaluate what is happening, and choose how you respond.”

Hypnosis does not require a person to surrender judgment or become unconscious. Contemporary clinical descriptions commonly present hypnosis as a state or condition involving focused attention, reduced attention to surrounding stimuli, and increased responsiveness to suggestions.⁴ The person’s participation remains central.

It may also help to ask what “strong-minded” means to them. Sometimes the phrase refers to concerns about losing control. Sometimes it means they expect to notice every word, analyze the process, or resist anything that feels imposed. Those concerns can be discussed openly rather than treated as a problem.

What if they are afraid of losing control?

A useful answer is:

“You do not have to agree to anything that conflicts with your values or wishes. We can stop at any time, and you can tell me if something feels uncomfortable or unhelpful.”

This does not promise that every person will have an identical experience. It simply explains the boundaries of a respectful hypnotic interaction. A person should know what will happen, what is being asked of them, and how they can pause or stop.

Professional hypnosis practice should include informed consent, clear communication, and attention to the person’s preferences. The hypnotist should not use pressure, deception, or exaggerated claims to overcome hesitation.

What if they say, “I tried hypnosis, and it did not work”?

Start by asking what they expected and what actually happened:

“What were you hoping to notice? What did you experience instead?”

People may expect hypnosis to feel like sleep, unconsciousness, total relaxation, or a dramatic loss of control. Others expect an immediate and unmistakable change. In practice, experiences vary. A person may remain aware of the room, notice their own thoughts, or feel only mild physical changes while still engaging with suggestions.

It is also possible that the method, setting, suggestions, or working relationship did not suit that person. A disappointing experience does not automatically establish that hypnosis is ineffective for them, but it also should not be explained away with certainty. The honest response is to review what happened and decide whether trying again makes sense.

Is resistance always a problem?

No. A person’s hesitation may communicate useful information. They may need more explanation, have had a negative experience, misunderstand what hypnosis involves, or simply decide that it is not for them.

Rather than labeling the person “resistant,” try asking:

  • “What concerns you most?”

  • “What would make you feel comfortable?”

  • “What would you want to remain in control of?”

  • “Would you prefer to learn more before deciding?”

  • “Would you rather use a different approach?”

This approach treats consent as ongoing rather than as an obstacle to overcome.

Does hypnosis require complete relaxation?

No. Deep physical relaxation is not the only way people may participate in hypnosis. Some hypnotic procedures use focused attention, imagery, mental rehearsal, or responses to suggestions. A person may be physically comfortable while still noticing thoughts, sounds, and bodily sensations.

A better explanation is:

“Relaxation can be part of some hypnosis sessions, but it is not the sole requirement. The main question is whether you are willing to focus and take part in the process.”

It is also wise not to make relaxation a performance requirement. Telling someone that they must relax perfectly can make them monitor themselves anxiously and conclude that they are failing.

What should you avoid saying?

Avoid statements that pressure, shame, or mislead the person, such as:

  • “You are too controlling.”

  • “You are blocking it.”

  • “If you do not go under, you are resisting.”

  • “Everyone can be hypnotized if they try hard enough.”

  • “You will lose control.”

  • “You will definitely get the result you want.”

  • “You cannot stop once we begin.”

These statements turn uncertainty into a personal defect or create expectations that hypnosis cannot responsibly guarantee. They may also undermine informed consent and trust.

What is a friendly, concise response?

You could say:

“That is completely okay. Hypnosis is not about being weak or losing control, and people respond to it in different ways. We can discuss what you expect and what concerns you have. If you want to try it, you can remain involved and stop at any point. If it does not feel right, we can choose another approach.”

This response is reassuring without making promises. It gives the person room to ask questions and make a free decision.

What if the person is asking about hypnotherapy?

When hypnosis is being considered as part of therapy, the conversation should include more than hypnotic responsiveness. The person should understand the purpose of the intervention, what the session will involve, what alternatives are available, and what evidence supports its use for the specific concern.

Hypnosis may be used in some clinical contexts, but it is not a universal treatment and should not be presented as a substitute for appropriate medical or psychological care. The suitability of any treatment depends on the person’s needs, goals, history, and preferences.

A careful response might be:

“We can discuss whether hypnotherapy is appropriate for your particular goal, what the process involves, and what other options you have. You do not need to decide before you have enough information.”

What is the main message?

The most helpful response does not try to win an argument. It respects the person’s autonomy, corrects common misconceptions without being condescending, and invites an honest conversation.

A simple answer is:

“You do not have to prove that you can be hypnotized. People respond differently, and you remain involved in the process. We can talk about your concerns, try only if you genuinely want to, and stop if it does not feel right.”

That combination of respect, clarity, and choice is usually more useful than insisting that hypnosis must work.

Notes

  1. Peter J. Lang and Patrick H. Whalen, “The Variable Nature of Hypnotic Responsiveness,” in Handbook of Clinical Hypnosis, edited by Steven J. Lynn, Irving Kirsch, and Judith W. Rhue, 2nd ed. (Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, 2010). The chapter discusses individual differences and contextual influences related to hypnotic responding.

  2. David Spiegel, “The Neuroscience of Hypnosis,” Psychiatric Annals 38, no. 7 (2008): 457–460. The article discusses hypnotizability as an individual difference and distinguishes hypnosis from simple sleep or unconsciousness.

  3. Steven J. Lynn, Judith W. Rhue, and Irving Kirsch, “Individual Differences in Hypnotic Suggestibility,” in International Handbook of Clinical Hypnosis, edited by Graham D. Burrows, Robert O. Stanley, and Peter B. Bloom (Chichester, UK: Wiley, 2001). The chapter addresses differences among individuals in responsiveness to hypnotic suggestions.

  4. Elvira V. Lang and Michael J. P. Quevillon, “Time-Dependent Effects of Hypnosis on Pain Perception,” Pain 58, no. 1 (1994): 9–15. The article provides a clinical description of hypnosis involving focused attention and altered responsiveness to suggestions in the context of pain research.


Was this article helpful?