What does “altered state of consciousness” mean?
“Altered state of consciousness” is a broad phrase, not a single, universally agreed-upon scientific category. It may refer to a noticeable change in perception, attention, memory, emotion, self-awareness, or the experience of time compared with ordinary waking awareness.
The phrase is useful in everyday discussion, but it can also create confusion. Some people hear “altered state” and assume that hypnosis must involve unconsciousness, loss of control, or a special condition that is completely separate from ordinary mental activity. Research does not support those assumptions.¹
Is hypnosis usually described as an altered state?
Sometimes. Many older theories of hypnosis treated it as a distinct state of consciousness. Other researchers have argued that hypnosis can be explained without proposing a separate state, emphasizing factors such as attention, expectations, motivation, social context, imagination, and the way people interpret suggestions.²
This disagreement is often called the state-versus-nonstate debate. It is not simply a dispute over whether hypnosis is “real.” Instead, it concerns how best to explain the changes that can occur during hypnosis and why people respond differently to suggestions.
A careful answer is therefore:
Hypnosis can involve changes in consciousness, but calling it a distinct altered state is a theoretical interpretation rather than an established fact accepted by all researchers.
What changes during hypnosis?
During hypnosis, a person may experience changes in several areas:
Attention: Attention may become more focused on selected ideas, sensations, memories, or images.
Absorption: A person may become deeply involved in an activity or internal experience.
Response to suggestion: Suggestions may produce changes in perception, movement, memory, or subjective experience.
Sense of agency: Some actions may feel as though they happen automatically rather than through deliberate effort.
Time perception: Time may seem to pass more quickly or slowly.
Self-awareness: A person may pay less attention to unrelated thoughts or outside distractions.
These experiences are not identical for everyone, and none is required for hypnosis. A person may remain aware of the surroundings, remember the session, and still respond meaningfully to suggestions. Hypnosis also does not require sleep.³
Does hypnosis involve unconsciousness?
No. Hypnosis is not the same as being unconscious, asleep, or medically unresponsive. People generally remain capable of hearing, understanding, evaluating, and responding during a hypnotic procedure.
The word “trance” is sometimes used to describe hypnosis, but it can be misleading if it suggests that the person has lost awareness. In many cases, the person knows where they are and what is happening. They may also be able to speak, ask questions, reject a suggestion, or end the exercise.
Hypnotic experiences can feel automatic, but an experience of automaticity does not prove that the person has become unconscious or lost all control. It describes how an action or sensation is experienced, not necessarily the underlying mechanism.
Does hypnosis produce a special brain state?
Research using brain-imaging and other physiological methods has found changes during hypnosis in brain activity and connectivity. Some studies have reported differences in networks involved in attention, cognitive control, self-related processing, and the monitoring of mental activity.⁴
These findings show that hypnosis can be associated with measurable changes in brain function. They do not, by themselves, establish that hypnosis is one unique biological state shared by everyone who is hypnotized.
Brain activity also changes during many ordinary experiences, including focused attention, emotional engagement, mental imagery, meditation, and responding to instructions. A pattern of change can be meaningful without proving that hypnosis is a single, clearly bounded state.
Is hypnosis simply relaxation?
Not necessarily. Relaxation may be included in some hypnotic procedures, but it is not the defining feature of hypnosis. A person can be physically relaxed and show little response to suggestion, while another person may respond to suggestions while remaining alert and physically active.
Some hypnotic exercises use calm breathing and comfortable body positioning. Others focus more directly on attention, imagery, expectation, or a particular suggested experience. Hypnosis is better understood as a structured interaction involving suggestion and attention than as relaxation alone.
Is hypnosis just pretending?
That conclusion is also too simple. Some people may consciously act along with a suggestion in a particular setting, while others report involuntary or highly compelling experiences. Research has found that hypnotic responsiveness varies considerably among individuals and can be influenced by expectations, social context, motivation, and the wording of suggestions.⁵
This does not mean that every hypnotic response is imaginary or that every response is entirely involuntary. Human behavior can involve both deliberate participation and experiences that feel automatic. A person may cooperate with a procedure while still experiencing a suggested sensation, movement, or image as unusually compelling.
Why do researchers disagree about hypnosis?
Researchers may be asking different questions.
One question is whether hypnosis includes a distinctive change in consciousness. Another is how people respond to suggestions in a particular social and instructional setting. A third concerns the brain systems associated with attention, expectation, imagery, and perceived control.
Different theories may explain different parts of the evidence. For example, a state-oriented account may focus on changes in attention and subjective experience, while a nonstate account may emphasize expectations, beliefs, context, and ordinary psychological processes. Some modern approaches combine these perspectives rather than treating them as mutually exclusive.
The debate also continues because “hypnosis” can refer to several related but different things:
A procedure involving instructions and suggestions.
A person’s subjective experience during that procedure.
A person’s measurable response to particular suggestions.
A proposed psychological or neurocognitive mechanism.
Keeping these meanings separate makes the discussion much clearer.
Can hypnosis change perception and memory?
Suggestions during hypnosis can influence subjective experiences such as pain, discomfort, vividness of imagery, and the perceived effort involved in an action. Hypnotic suggestions may also affect memory performance, but this area requires particular care.
Hypnosis should not be treated as a reliable method for recovering accurate memories. Memory is reconstructive and can be influenced by suggestion, expectation, and questioning. In legal or investigative settings, hypnotically influenced recall may increase confidence without ensuring accuracy.⁶
For that reason, hypnosis is not a sound substitute for independent evidence when someone is trying to determine what actually happened.
Does calling hypnosis an altered state make it more effective?
No. The label itself does not establish effectiveness. Whether hypnosis is useful depends on the purpose, the person, the quality of the procedure, the skill and qualifications of the practitioner, and the evidence for the specific problem being addressed.
For some clinical applications, hypnosis may be used as an adjunct to an established treatment. Evidence varies by condition and by study design, so broad statements that hypnosis works for everyone or produces the same results for all problems are not justified. A qualified health professional can help determine whether a particular use is appropriate.
What is the most accurate short answer?
Hypnosis is associated with changes in attention, suggestion response, perception, and subjective experience. It can therefore be described as involving an altered mode of consciousness in an ordinary-language sense. However, whether it is a distinct “altered state of consciousness” in a strict scientific sense remains debated.
The safest summary is:
Hypnosis is a structured psychological procedure that can produce meaningful changes in experience and behavior. Those changes do not require unconsciousness, and the evidence does not require us to treat hypnosis as one unique state separate from all ordinary forms of attention and expectation.
Notes
Michael R. Nash, “The Truth and the Hype of Hypnosis,” Scientific American 274, no. 2 (1996): 48–54.
Irving Kirsch and Steven Jay Lynn, “The Altered State of Hypnosis: Changes in the Sense of Self and the Role of the Unconscious,” in Theories of Hypnosis: Current Models and Perspectives, edited by Steven Jay Lynn, Judith W. Rhue, and Irving Kirsch, 3–22 (New York: Guilford Press, 1999).
Michael R. Nash and Grant Sollmann, “Hypnosis and Suggestion,” in The Oxford Handbook of Hypnosis: Theory, Research, and Practice, edited by Michael R. Nash and Amanda J. Barnier, 3–23 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008).
David Spiegel, Matthew D. White, and Jennifer M. H. Waelde, “Neuroimaging of Hypnosis and Meditation,” in The Oxford Handbook of Hypnosis: Theory, Research, and Practice, edited by Michael R. Nash and Amanda J. Barnier, 581–610 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008).
Irving Kirsch, “Response Expectancy as a Determinant of Experience and Behavior,” American Psychologist 40, no. 11 (1985): 1189–1202.
Elizabeth F. Loftus, “Planting Misinformation in the Human Mind: A 30-Year Investigation of the Malleability of Memory,” Learning & Memory 12, no. 4 (2005): 361–366.